Welcome! Log In Create A New Profile


Why do we only have Major and Minor keys?

Posted by evo 
Why do we only have Major and Minor keys?
July 16, 2020 09:19AM
So why do we only have Major and Minor keys?

What about diminished and augmented keys?

Re: Why do we only have Major and Minor keys?
July 16, 2020 08:17PM
Hi; im not sure as whether there are musical pieces written in keys other than either major or minor; theoretically perhaps, it could be thought of a piece whith starting and ending chord being a diminished (or augmented) chord. It may be the case that there are so many (indeed, infinite) different ways to develope a piece starting either in a major or minor chord, that historically those keys had attracted the main effort by composers and music artists of all time, so to speak. Greetings
Re: Why do we only have Major and Minor keys?
December 21, 2020 06:25PM
It's mostly historical. Gregorian Chant was written without much thought given to keys or the like; it was melodic only, but there were traditional composition procedures. Later, people tried to classify chant as to its characteristics; some chants were clearly related in style and form. This procedure gave rise to eight modes comprising four ending notes (D,E,F,G) and ranges basically D-D or A-A and E-E and B-B and F-F and C-C and G-G and D-D. Amusingly the note Bb was in existence by the time this classification was made. The F mode sometimes had a Bb which made it equivalent to a (hypothetical) mode on C.

As music underwent changes, more modes were suggested and pieces could have parts written in other than their beginning modes; this led to the addition of more notes like Bb (Eb to start with, etc.) In parallel with this was a 6-note pattern called the Hexachord system (it's worth reading the Wiki on hexachords. It's complicated and more so when combined with the chant modes,

During the 1300-1500 time frame, harmonic concepts were expanded into the current scheme used now, but not with the same usages. The chords (triads anyway) were known and used but a good description wasn't available. The musicians (as usual) outran the theorists.

By the 1600s, it was clear the that modes on D and E (as then used) were characterized by the having a minor third (D to F and E to G respectively); the modes on F and G were characterized by having a major third (F-A and G-B) similarly placed. It was recognized that modes on A and C were also becoming common.

Because of the above characterization of the modes, those with a minor third at the beginning (A,D,E) were termed minor and those starting with a major third (A,F,G) were called major.

Composers also found that the distinction between major and minor was greater that that between other possible modes.
Re: Why do we only have Major and Minor keys?
April 10, 2021 11:49AM
Strictly speaking we don't. There are many other "modes".

Each mode has a different template for the pattern of Tones and Semitones between each note of the scale.

The pattern for the Ionian Mode is: TTSTTTS

Which is identical to the pattern for our Major scale today.

The pattern for the Dorian Mode is: TSTTTST

This can be regarded as a minor mode (due to the minor 3rd). The "standard" minor mode now would have been regarded as the Aeolian mode by our musician predecessors.

There are a number of other modes (based on the note they end on - the "finalis"). Some correspond to our various minor scales (harmonic, melodic, ascending and descending) and others just sound odd now to the western ear brought up with equal temperament tuning and our broad division of our music into just Major and Minor modes.

The whole area of "modes" is fascinating, if a little confusing for those of us brought up in the modern western tradition. Even in that though there are many remnants of our modal music past; the various minor scales we still have, the "tierce de Picardie" demanded in earlier music but somewhat optional today.

There are even some well-known modal melodies lurking around. The melody of "What shall we do with the drunken sailor?" is actually in the Dorian mode.

I could drone about parallel modes and all other kinds of musical scales but I won't. There is a lot of information available on dedicated Internet sites any of which I'd recommend for a fuller and more fascinating explanation.

Re: Why do we only have Major and Minor keys?
May 21, 2022 08:25PM
Yes, there is more than Major and minor.

Try playing Baa baa Black sheep starting from C on the piano. Then do it starting from all the other white notes using the same intervals (differences between the notes) and you will find the same tune varied on each one.

These are different scales or modes and there are many many of them. I have a guitar suite sheet music by Luis Milan
where a part of the same piece changes from Majot to to Dorian (The "scale" or mode starting on the D of the piano.) and back again to Major.

Keep well
Sorry, only registered users may post in this forum.

Click here to login